Punting on Academics

POSTED: Nov 09, 2012 11:05 AM
By Alex Tate

Nothing excites Americans more than football. The last three Super Bowls were the most watched television events ever in the United States. With the NCAA poised to profit more than ever when it moves to a playoff system in 2014, debate swirls over compensation for student athletes and institutional spending on athletics. But does college football detract from students’ academic performance?

In the October 2012 issue of American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, Jason Lindo, Isaac Swensen, and Glen Waddell tracked students’ grades during the football season at the University of Oregon from 1997 from 2007. As the Ducks' winning percentage went up—the team finished the 2001 season in the top five nationally—the grades of male non-athletes took a dive. The gap between male and female GPAs widened, and boys were more likely to receive failing grades. Girls’ performance may have suffered too, but the practice of grading on a curve obscures a clear answer. In a survey designed by the authors, both sexes said that the Ducks' wins fueled alcohol consumption, but males were more likely to party harder and study less.

The good news is that a winning football team doesn’t seem to do longer term damage to students’ careers. In fact, among girls with lower than average SAT scores and/or high financial need, the Ducks' winning streaks reduced the probability of dropping out. These girls could have been the main

... READ THE REST OF THIS ENTRY >>

COMMENT (1) >>

Recent Posts

What We're Reading

WQ editors share their winter weather reads.

Dilemma of a Football Fan

If football is harmful to players, is it ethical to be a fan?

Prickly German Privacy

Germans know how to enjoy themselves during the holidays, but don’t invade their Internet privacy.

Food and Rhetoric

Two new books illuminate politics high and low—the role of high principle and the urgency of land grabs around the world.

Punting on Academics

College football success upends boys’ grades, but girls may actually benefit.

A Pilgrimage to Ukraine: The Story Behind a Photo

One photographer's journey to trace his family roots yielded an image for our fall issue. 

WilosonQuarterly.com wilsoncenter.org