Putting Theory to the Test

by Edward J. Larson

WHAT DARWIN GOT WRONG. By Jerry Fodor and Massimo Piattelli-Palmarini. Farrar, Straus & Giroux. 264 pp. $26

Americans love conspiracy theories. Many still think that shadowy plotters continue to cover up the identity of JFK’s “real” killers, and the popular notion that climate change is a hoax perpetrated by a cabal ofself-interested scientists is now enjoying its second or third wind. Thelongest-running conspiracy theory in science, however, depicts a fiendishly complex effort by scientists over the past 150 years to prop up a bankrupt Darwinian theory in spite of what its critics see as massive andself-evident flaws. Although nothing in What Darwin Got Wrong suggests that the authors, Rutgers University philosophy professor Jerry Fodor and cognitive scientist MassimoPiattelli-Palmarini, believe that a conspiracy is afoot, their writing follows the usualpattern.

---

If you want ...